AI Match Summaries

One-line AI headline and voting-anomaly flags for every contest match, from a ChatGPT pass over the Board 8 wiki writeups (CC BY-SA 3.0). Machine-generated — may contain mistakes. The full narrative shows under each row (hide narratives).

Researching with your own AI? Grab the Board 8 wiki corpus for context.

See also: AI Contest Summaries

Contest: All · SC2K2 · SC2K3 · Spring 2K4 · SC2K4 · Spring 2K5 · SC2K5 · BSE2K6 · CB2K6 · CB VI · CB VII · BGE 2K9 · CB VIII · GOTD · Rivalry · CB IX · BGE 2K15 · Best Year · CB X · GOTD 2

Entrant:

Anomaly: any · SFF · LFF · Rally · Cheat · Pic · off-topic writeups

Round: all · Wildcard · Round 1 · Round 2 · Round 3 · Division Semifinal · Division Final · Legends · Redemption · Final Nine · Quarterfinal · Semifinal · Final · Final Battle · Tournament of Champions · Battle Royale · Bonus (round labels are specific to contests)

Filtered: contest = Game of the Decade (2010)   — 127 of 1,514 matches   show all

127 matches · 1 bonus hidden — show bonus

# Poll ▼ Contest Round Division Result Headline SFF LFF Rally Cheat Pic n
1 4195
writeup (md)
GOTD Final Majora's Mask wins the Game of the Decade crown

Majora's Mask carried its momentum into the final and built enough of an early advantage to survive Brawl's later daytime recovery. The writeup frames the result as both a Good-vs-Evil fanbase victory and a symbolic win for older games over newer ones.

2 4194
writeup (md)
GOTD Semifinal Majora's Mask rallies through an all-time semifinal classic 1

Final Fantasy X controlled much of the first half, Majora's Mask mounted a huge daytime comeback, and FFX nearly answered again late. The writeup calls it the best match of the contest and a throwback to the site's classic close-match era.

Rally: The writeup says Majora's Mask was rallied more heavily and that its fans pushed harder during the decisive stages of the close semifinal.

3 4193
writeup (md)
GOTD Semifinal
Fallout 3 45.6%
Fallout 3 gives Brawl a major semifinal warning

Fallout 3 performed far better against Brawl than the writeup expected and resisted even Brawl's normally dominant daytime strength. The result is framed as an excellent loss and as evidence of growing voter fatigue with Nintendo and Square dominance.

4 4192
writeup (md)
GOTD Quarterfinal Majora's Mask turns into a genuine title threat

Majora's Mask overwhelmed Metal Gear Solid 3 and fully emerged as a credible championship threat. The writeup considers MGS3 the one quarterfinalist that looked clearly out of place this deep in the bracket.

5 4191
writeup (md)
GOTD Quarterfinal Final Fantasy X destroys the Resident Evil 4 upset hype

Final Fantasy X erased the pre-match Resident Evil 4 upset hype almost immediately and produced the writeup's strongest championship-looking performance of its run. RE4 is treated as a major disappointment for failing to make the match competitive.

6 4190
writeup (md)
GOTD Quarterfinal Brawl suppresses Twilight Princess and strengthens its title case 1

Twilight Princess briefly led before Brawl took over and won comfortably. The result made Brawl look increasingly difficult to stop and strengthened the belief that it was the contest favorite.

SFF: The writeup says Brawl versus Twilight Princess can be considered SFF because of their shared Nintendo/Wii audience, with Brawl suppressing Zelda's support.

7 4189
writeup (md)
GOTD Quarterfinal
Fallout 3 51.9%
Fallout 3 survives Prime in a timing-sensitive quarterfinal

Fallout 3 survived a strong Metroid Prime challenge, with the writeup again arguing that match timing may have changed the outcome. The recent New Vegas release is also cited as a plausible boost for Fallout.

8 4188
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Final Northwest Majora's Mask settles the Wind Waker debate

Majora's Mask settled a long-running Zelda-series debate by beating Wind Waker decisively. The writeup argues the result did not require any special contest bandwagon because Majora was simply the more beloved title.

9 4187
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Final West Night voting ends the Shadow of the Colossus run

Metal Gear Solid 3 ended the Shadow of the Colossus Cinderella run in a match the writeup believes was heavily shaped by being held at night. Shadow stayed close, but MGS3's overnight strength controlled the decisive portion.

10 4186
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Final Southwest
Portal 44.5%
Portal exits with one of the contest's best runs

Portal's run ended against Resident Evil 4, but the writeup still considers the showing highly respectable and much stronger than old four-way statistics would have implied. It treats Portal as one of the contest's major success stories.

11 4185
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Final South Final Fantasy X cruises through a mild Square SFF match 1

The same-series divisional final was never presented as a serious rivalry, and Final Fantasy IX was simply outclassed by Final Fantasy X. The writeup mostly uses the match to criticize how easy the division had been for FFX.

SFF: The writeup treats this as a Square SFF matchup, noting that Final Fantasy IX was suppressed by Final Fantasy X even if the effect was milder than some older Square pairings.

12 4184
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Final Southeast Twilight Princess makes the four-way comparison look useless

Twilight Princess overwhelmed Kingdom Hearts II far more decisively than their earlier four-way meeting had suggested. The writeup uses the result as another example of Zelda's exceptional 1v1 strength and the unreliability of four-way comparisons.

13 4183
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Final East Brawl comes back on Melee in a divisive rivalry match

Melee built the early lead, but Brawl's European and morning strength completed the comeback and settled the rivalry for the bracket. The writeup argues that the timing format may have mattered enough to make the result less definitive than the rivalry deserved.

14 4182
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Final Northeast Prime advances as Half-Life 2 exposes a timing problem

Metroid Prime controlled the match, while Half-Life 2's late gains suggested that a different time window might have produced a much closer result. The writeup explicitly says the heavily discussed pictures did not matter.

15 4181
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Final North
Fallout 3 60.6%
Fallout 3 delivers its first fully convincing statement

The poll disappeared entirely for the opening hour, but the eventual match gave Fallout 3 its first clear statement against a proven contest game. The writeup treats the result as the moment serious upset talk against Fallout largely died.

16 4180
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Semifinal Northwest Wind Waker quietly ends Oblivion's hoped-for challenge

Wind Waker handled Oblivion without the competitive drama some had expected before the contest. Oblivion improved during the day but never became one of the Western games the writeup considered especially impressive.

17 4179
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Semifinal Northwest Majora's Mask destroys the Pokémon GSC hype

Majora's Mask ended the heavily hyped Pokémon GSC run almost immediately and overturned the comparisons many people had drawn from the prior four-way contest. The writeup treats the result as another major rejection of four-way extrapolation.

18 4178
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Semifinal West Shadow of the Colossus confirms its Cinderella run

Shadow of the Colossus followed its MGS2 upset by beating Metal Gear Solid 4 and turning a possible fluke into the contest's defining Cinderella run. A late MGS4 rally cut into the lead but is explicitly dismissed as meaningless.

19 4177
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Semifinal West Paper Mario exits with its credibility intact

Paper Mario's run ended against Metal Gear Solid 3, but the writeup treats its performance as fully legitimate after the earlier World of Warcraft upset. It also mocks how badly casual brackets had overestimated WoW's chances in this section.

20 4176
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Semifinal Southwest
Portal 54.3%
Mass Effect shines in defeat against Portal

Portal beat Mass Effect comfortably, but the writeup considers Mass Effect's showing one of the best losses of the contest and clear proof of a major sequel-driven boost. Portal still looked strong, just not strong enough to threaten Resident Evil 4.

21 4175
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Semifinal Southwest Resident Evil 4 revives its Final Fantasy X upset case

Resident Evil 4 rebounded from its weak Vice City match by crushing Persona 4. Combined with Final Fantasy X's poor showing, the result revived serious discussion of an RE4 upset in the next round.

22 4174
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Semifinal South Final Fantasy IX survives a respectable KOTOR challenge

Final Fantasy IX held off KOTOR in a matchup that had been a legitimate pre-contest upset possibility. KOTOR's respectable loss and FFIX's predictable daytime decline left the writeup satisfied with both games' performances.

23 4173
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Semifinal South Final Fantasy X survives another ugly performance

Final Fantasy X beat Golden Sun but looked embarrassingly weak early in a matchup where the writeup expected major same-genre suppression. Its overnight recovery helped, yet the result reinforced the view that FFX had declined substantially since 2004.

24 4172
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Semifinal Southeast Kingdom Hearts II wins the series showdown

Kingdom Hearts II upset the original Kingdom Hearts in a direct series showdown, repeatedly repelling small comeback attempts before its strong afternoon vote pulled away. The writeup treats the result as decisive evidence that the sequel had become the stronger game.

25 4171
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Semifinal Southeast Galaxy loses to Zelda but earns new respect

Twilight Princess eliminated Super Mario Galaxy, but Galaxy performed far better than the old Mario-versus-Zelda history suggested it might. The writeup treats the loss as a moral victory that helped rehabilitate Galaxy's contest reputation.

26 4170
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Semifinal East Brawl mauls Pokémon and takes the Melee edge

Brawl destroyed Pokémon DPP even in a daytime match favorable to Pokémon. The writeup treats the performance as decisive evidence that Brawl had overtaken Melee in the divisional rivalry.

27 4169
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Semifinal East Melee wins while the Brawl warning signs pile up

Melee beat Call of Duty 4 easily but again bled enough support to make the writeup increasingly pessimistic about its chances against Brawl. The poor bracket confidence around Melee added to the warning signs.

28 4168
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Semifinal Northeast Half-Life 2 crushes the God of War upset case

Half-Life 2 immediately shut down pre-match God of War upset talk and delivered one of its strongest performances. The result turned the coming Metroid Prime matchup into a genuine tossup.

29 4167
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Semifinal Northeast
Okami 41.8%
Okami earns respect in defeat against Metroid Prime

Metroid Prime advanced as expected, but Okami's resistance impressed the writeup and validated how far the game had risen since its earliest contest appearances. The result briefly made Prime's next match look more uncertain than it ultimately was.

30 4166
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Semifinal North Halo's ASV overwhelms Uncharted 2

Halo transformed an almost even opening hour against Uncharted 2 into a decisive win through its trademark afternoon vote. The writeup treats the swing as a classic demonstration of Halo's unusually powerful ASV.

31 4165
writeup (md)
GOTD Division Semifinal North
Fallout 3 58.8%
Batman validates itself in a respectable Fallout loss

Fallout 3 beat Batman without suspense, but Batman's respectable showing reinforced the writeup's view that Arkham Asylum was a genuinely strong new entrant. The match mattered more for Batman's validation than for the winner.

32 4164
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 Northwest Paper Mario exposes Oblivion as a four-way wonder

Oblivion beat Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door, but the margin was far too small to sustain pre-contest talk of challenging Wind Waker. The writeup treats Paper Mario's resistance as another strong showing for the series.

33 4163
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 Northwest Assassin's Creed II makes Wind Waker look vulnerable

Wind Waker began overwhelmingly against Assassin's Creed II and then bled support at a rate the writeup considered shocking for Zelda. The result both lowered confidence in Wind Waker and established Assassin's Creed II as a legitimate contest game.

34 4162
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 Northwest Pokémon GSC keeps pace with Majora's Mask

Pokémon GSC answered Majora's benchmark with an even larger blowout of Mario Kart Wii. The result kept their coming matchup debatable while also extending the writeup's criticism of Wii-era contest strength.

35 4161
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 Northwest Majora's Mask sets the benchmark for Pokémon GSC

Majora's Mask crushed Chrono Cross in a routine second-round blowout. The writeup uses the result mainly to establish a benchmark for Pokémon GSC before their anticipated clash.

36 4160
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 West Shadow of the Colossus survives MGS2 in a classic 2

Shadow of the Colossus survived an all-day war of attrition against Metal Gear Solid 2 and won by the narrowest margin in the contest. The writeup treats the upset as the launch of the contest's Cinderella run and one of its best matches.

Pic · Rally: The writeup calls Shadow of the Colossus's image the biggest picture disadvantage of the contest and says it would have won more easily under fairer pictures. It also explicitly describes a late Shadow of the Colossus counter-rally after MGS2 retook the lead.

37 4159
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 West
Diablo II 45.1%
Diablo II exposes a weakened Metal Gear Solid 4

Metal Gear Solid 4 won but steadily lost ground to Diablo II and looked far weaker than its prior-year form. The writeup also gives Diablo II substantial credit as the strongest traditional Western RPG in the field.

38 4158
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 West Paper Mario humiliates heavily favored World of Warcraft

Paper Mario decisively eliminated World of Warcraft in a matchup casual brackets had badly misread. The writeup treats the result as the clearest humiliation of WoW's inflated seeding and popularity expectations.

39 4157
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 West MGS3 wins while Marvel looks more legitimate

Metal Gear Solid 3 beat Marvel vs. Capcom 2, but looked weak enough to worry observers who had dismissed MvC2's first-round rally-assisted upset. The writeup retrospectively credits MvC2 with more legitimate strength than it initially received.

40 4156
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 Southwest Mass Effect ends Skies of Arcadia's upset run

Mass Effect ended Skies of Arcadia's upset run with a predictable blowout. The writeup treats the match mainly as confirmation of the large boost Mass Effect received from its sequel.

41 4155
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 Southwest
Portal 60.0%
Portal blows away Final Fantasy XII

Portal demolished Final Fantasy XII in a matchup that had been heavily debated before the contest. The writeup celebrates the result as both a Portal statement and a decisive rejection of old four-way extrapolations favoring FFXII.

42 4154
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 Southwest Persona 4 survives Dead Rising in a late thriller 1

Persona 4 survived a long Dead Rising comeback in one of the round's closest races, reclaiming control late after briefly falling behind. The writeup credits Persona's more committed fanbase and possibly its picture for the narrow escape.

Pic: The writeup explicitly says Persona 4's strong match picture may deserve credit for the narrow win over Dead Rising.

43 4153
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 Southwest Resident Evil 4 bleeds away its title hype

Resident Evil 4 began with championship-level numbers against Vice City, then bled support for the entire match. The writeup treats the final result as a major warning that RE4's deeper title aspirations were unrealistic.

44 4152
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 South Final Fantasy IX finally avoids a daytime collapse

Final Fantasy IX routed Persona 3 and, unusually, avoided its customary daytime collapse. The writeup treats the result as routine but mildly encouraging for FFIX's trend profile.

45 4151
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 South KOTOR wins but loses its Final Fantasy IX hype

KOTOR beat Fire Emblem but struggled enough to erase most hopes of an upset over Final Fantasy IX. The writeup regards Fire Emblem as respectable but not strong enough to excuse KOTOR's middling performance.

46 4150
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 South Golden Sun upsets San Andreas with everything breaking its way 1

Golden Sun upset San Andreas on the release day of Dark Dawn, with RPG-friendly site conditions and a prominent home-page ad further favoring the winner. The writeup sees the timing as unusually hostile to GTA and the result as a major casual-bracket shock.

Pic: The writeup says Golden Sun's match picture looked exceptionally strong while San Andreas looked exceptionally poor, describing the image as one of several factors stacked against GTA.

47 4149
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 South Final Fantasy X finally delivers a clean blowout

Final Fantasy X delivered one of its few clean performances of the contest by overwhelming Borderlands and holding steady throughout the match. The writeup still regards the result as an exception rather than proof that FFX had fully returned to old form.

48 4148
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 Southeast Kingdom Hearts humiliates Modern Warfare 2

Kingdom Hearts doubled Modern Warfare 2, an especially harsh result because Kingdom Hearts rarely produces or suffers major blowouts. The writeup treats the match as another humiliating verdict on Call of Duty's standing on the site.

49 4147
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 Southeast
BioShock 43.7%
Kingdom Hearts II survives heavy BioShock respect

Kingdom Hearts II beat a highly respected BioShock despite much of the prediction community siding against it. The writeup sees BioShock's strong loss as evidence of a contest-title boost while also noting how easily KH2 survived.

50 4146
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 Southeast Twilight Princess dispatches a badly placed Dragon Age

Twilight Princess comfortably eliminated Dragon Age in a match whose seeding and bracket placement left little suspense. The writeup argues that Dragon Age could have done more in a less hostile part of the bracket.

51 4145
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 Southeast Galaxy wins an oddly weak match against Pokémon RSE

Super Mario Galaxy beat Pokémon RSE but looked much weaker than expected while doing so. The writeup retrospectively treats the result as a strange outlier in an otherwise strong Galaxy contest.

52 4144
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 East Brawl cruises but gives Melee one small opening

Brawl demolished Valkyria Chronicles, though the writeup considers this one of the few matches where Brawl looked merely comparable to Melee rather than clearly superior. The result itself was never competitive.

53 4143
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 East Pokémon DPP advances without inspiring title confidence

Pokémon Diamond, Pearl and Platinum eliminated Fire Emblem as expected, but failed to look strong enough to support the most ambitious Pokémon projections. The writeup treats the match as bad news for hopes of a broader Pokémon surge.

54 4142
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 East Perfect Dark embarrasses Call of Duty despite the picture 1

Call of Duty 4 won but was badly embarrassed by an otherwise unproven Perfect Dark. The writeup sees the poor showing as further evidence of deep anti-Call-of-Duty sentiment on GameFAQs.

Pic: The writeup explicitly describes a picture imbalance against Perfect Dark and notes that Perfect Dark still performed well despite its weaker image.

55 4141
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 East Melee wins big but the Brawl warning signs grow

Melee posted another blowout, but its overnight and morning trends looked increasingly unfavorable for the looming match with Brawl. The writeup treats the performance as one of several signs that Brawl had become the favorite.

56 4140
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 Northeast GTA III earns respect while Half-Life 2 shows weakness

Grand Theft Auto III gave Half-Life 2 a strong challenge without ever threatening the actual result. The writeup treats GTA3 as the clear exception to the series' poor contest and sees Half-Life 2's steady bleed as a warning before stronger day-match opponents.

57 4139
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 Northeast God of War breaks a five-hour Tales deadlock

God of War and Tales of Symphonia spent hours in a true deadlock before God of War's morning vote broke the match open. The writeup remembers the long stall and decisive finish as one of the contest's best matches.

58 4138
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 Northeast
Okami 56.3%
Mega Man 9 impresses despite an easy Okami win

Okami beat Mega Man 9 comfortably, but Mega Man still performed well above the broader prediction consensus. The writeup treats the loss as validation that Mega Man 9 was a surprisingly legitimate entrant.

59 4137
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 Northeast Metroid Prime advances but leaves divisional questions

Metroid Prime comfortably eliminated Devil May Cry 3, though the winner's substantial percentage bleed kept questions alive about the divisional race. The writeup finds the match picture more memorable than the result.

60 4136
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 North
Halo 3 43.1%
Halo 1 settles the series hierarchy over Halo 3

Halo: Combat Evolved decisively beat Halo 3 and settled the series hierarchy in favor of the original. The writeup notes that the result was not an extreme same-series suppression, but was still a clear inter-series win.

61 4135
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 North Uncharted 2 wins a pyrrhic victory over Street Fighter IV

Uncharted 2 won, but its steady percentage loss to Street Fighter IV made the victory feel hollow. The writeup treats the result as a warning that either Halo game would be favored next round.

62 4134
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 North Batman crushes Team Fortress 2 and sparks new upset talk

Batman turned a matchup that had gained upset buzz after Team Fortress 2's first-round thriller into a one-sided win. The result immediately generated a new wave of Batman-over-Fallout speculation.

63 4133
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 2 North
Fallout 3 74.3%
Deus Ex 25.7%
Fallout 3 restores order against Deus Ex

Fallout 3 crushed first-round upset winner Deus Ex and restored the expected hierarchy. The writeup briefly entertains SFF as a possibility but ultimately treats Deus Ex as simply weak and focuses on Fallout's strong daytime profile.

64 4132
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Northwest Oblivion closes a wild first round without drama

Oblivion dispatched SoulCalibur II without the usual last-match-of-round chaos. The writeup mainly uses the quiet finish to reflect on an unusually entertaining and upset-heavy first round.

65 4131
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Northwest Paper Mario punishes the casual Gears of War pick

Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door comfortably beat a Gears of War side that casual brackets had favored heavily. The writeup treats the result as a clear victory for expert expectations over casual name recognition.

66 4130
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Northwest
ICO 38.1%
Assassin's Creed II advances in a difficult match to read

Assassin's Creed II won a largely static and hard-to-read match between lightly tested games. The writeup mostly uses the result to puzzle over the relative strength of Assassin's Creed, ICO and Metal Gear.

67 4129
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Northwest Wind Waker wins while old Celda hostility resurfaces

Wind Waker began overwhelmingly but lost a remarkable amount of support across the match. The writeup reads the collapse as evidence that lingering hostility toward the game still mattered and that it was in trouble against the Majora-GSC winner.

68 4128
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Northwest Pokémon GSC wins but loses ground in the title debate

Pokémon Gold, Silver and Crystal won easily but bled enough support to strengthen the writeup's belief that Majora's Mask was the stronger title. The match is framed as an early warning for Pokémon's championship hopes.

69 4127
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Northwest Mario Kart Wii barely avoids a Phoenix Wright embarrassment

Mario Kart Wii needed its morning strength to escape a surprisingly persistent Phoenix Wright challenge. The writeup treats the near-upset as one of the clearest embarrassments for the Wii in the contest.

70 4126
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Northwest Chrono Cross restores order in an SFF-tinged 8/9 match 1

Chrono Cross delivered one of the rare first-round 8/9 results that behaved roughly as expected. The writeup mostly celebrates the absence of another bracket disaster after a long run of chaotic 8/9 matches.

SFF: The writeup explicitly calls Chrono Cross versus Dragon Quest VIII a JRPG SFF match, with the stronger shared-audience title suppressing the weaker one.

71 4125
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Northwest Majora's Mask opens with championship-level strength

Majora's Mask opened with a performance the writeup retrospectively identifies as championship caliber. The result is presented as the first real evidence that the supposedly secondary Zelda title could win the entire contest.

72 4124
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 West
The Sims 30.7%
Shadow of the Colossus wins without revealing its future upset

Shadow of the Colossus handled The Sims comfortably despite surprisingly weak prediction support. The writeup stresses that the result still offered almost no reason to expect the major upset waiting in the next round.

73 4123
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 West Metal Gear Solid 2 gives no warning of what comes next

Metal Gear Solid 2 looked solid enough against Banjo-Tooie that nothing in the first round hinted at its coming loss to Shadow of the Colossus. The writeup emphasizes how misleading the opening-round evidence turned out to be.

74 4122
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 West
Diablo II 74.3%
Diablo II becomes Blizzard's bright spot

Diablo II produced a notably strong opening while the other Blizzard games were struggling badly. The writeup treats it as evidence that Diablo had benefited more than its Blizzard siblings from the contest's decade framing.

75 4121
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 West Metal Gear Solid 4 underperforms despite a picture disadvantage 1

Metal Gear Solid 4 won but looked substantially weaker than its 2009 form, reinforcing the emerging narrative that the entire series had declined. The writeup acknowledges the unfavorable picture while still treating the performance as poor.

Pic: The writeup explicitly says Metal Gear Solid 4 had a picture disadvantage against Assassin's Creed, though it argues that the disadvantage does not fully excuse MGS4's weak showing.

76 4120
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 West World of Warcraft collapses under massive anti-voting

World of Warcraft badly underperformed against one of Nintendo's weakest contest entrants despite receiving enormous bracket confidence. The writeup treats the result as a striking demonstration of how much anti-WoW sentiment mattered on GameFAQs.

77 4119
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 West Paper Mario looks far more legitimate than expected

Paper Mario looked far stronger than many pre-contest projections had suggested and immediately weakened the case for a World of Warcraft upset next round. The writeup also notes how much Katamari's old Board 8 popularity had faded.

78 4118
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 West SRK rallies Marvel past New Super Mario Bros. Wii 1

A close Mario lead gradually disappeared once the fighting-game community began rallying for Marvel vs. Capcom 2. The writeup remembers the result as one of the contest's largest public rally successes and a major bracket killer.

Rally: The writeup says Shoryuken.com organized an effective rally for Marvel vs. Capcom 2, producing the decisive late swing against New Super Mario Bros. Wii.

79 4117
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 West Metal Gear Solid 3 opens with a warning sign

Metal Gear Solid 3 won easily yet still looked weak for a top seed against a vote-in survivor. The writeup calls this an early warning for the entire Metal Gear division and for the series' contest strength.

80 4116
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Southwest Mass Effect underperforms despite sequel-fueled hype

Mass Effect's prediction support reflected a major boost from its sequel, but the actual performance fell well short of that reputation. The writeup considers this enough to make Portal the clear lower-bracket favorite.

81 4115
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Southwest Skies survives a dramatic Baldur's Gate collapse

Skies of Arcadia built a huge early advantage and then spent the rest of the match steadily giving it back. The writeup remembers the percentage collapse as unusually dramatic even though Baldur's Gate II never quite completed the comeback.

82 4114
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Southwest Final Fantasy XII wins a Pyrrhic victory

Final Fantasy XII won but looked weak enough against Crisis Core that the writeup labels the result a Pyrrhic victory. The showing effectively made Portal the clear favorite for their later matchup.

83 4113
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Southwest
Portal 71.5%
Portal explodes into a serious divisional threat

Portal crushed a game that had performed very well in the vote-ins and immediately locked down the Southwest's lower half. The writeup sees both its cult status and recent free availability as plausible contributors to its surge.

84 4112
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Southwest
Braid 36.0%
Persona 4 advances without settling the next round

Persona 4 advanced as expected but did not dominate enough to become a clear favorite over Dead Rising. The writeup sees the performance as mildly disappointing given Braid's presumed weakness.

85 4111
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Southwest Dead Rising survives a long TWEWY battle

The World Ends With You and Dead Rising produced a long, genuinely competitive match with several lead changes and a strong overnight Square push. The writeup treats the result as the real beginning of a tightly contested three-game section of the bracket.

86 4110
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Southwest Vice City delivers one of the contest's worst performances

Vice City performed so poorly that the writeup calls it one of the contest's biggest stinkers. The result is used as further evidence that Grand Theft Auto had become one of GameFAQs' most heavily disliked series.

87 4109
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Southwest Resident Evil 4 opens like a true title contender

Resident Evil 4 delivered the kind of emphatic opening expected from a serious title contender. The writeup argues that the 'Game of the Decade' framing may have boosted the game's already substantial respect.

88 4108
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 South Final Fantasy IX's day-vote weakness shows again

Final Fantasy IX handled Phoenix Wright comfortably but again displayed its famously weak afternoon trend. The writeup treats that pattern as an important warning for its upcoming daytime match with KOTOR.

89 4107
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 South Persona 3 gives the top-option rule another win

Persona 3 won a low-interest tossup that the writeup again uses to champion the 'top option' heuristic in pure fodder matches. The result mattered more for bracket psychology than for either game's strength.

90 4106
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 South Fire Emblem makes Tony Hawk look overmatched

Fire Emblem made a previously debated matchup with Tony Hawk look easy after its sister title had already crushed WWF No Mercy. The writeup treats the result as another rejection of sports and sports-adjacent games on the site.

91 4105
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 South KOTOR wins but bleeds away its upset case

Knights of the Old Republic won but steadily bled strength throughout the match. The writeup sees the decline as a major warning before its projected clash with Final Fantasy IX.

92 4104
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 South San Andreas fails to answer Golden Sun's challenge

San Andreas produced only an average performance at exactly the wrong time, with a new Golden Sun release looming over their next matchup. The writeup treats the result as a serious blow to GTA's chances.

93 4103
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 South Golden Sun looks far stronger than expected

Golden Sun looked unexpectedly legitimate against weak but recognizable opposition. The writeup immediately turns the result into a warning for Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas in the next round.

94 4102
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 South Borderlands restores order to a chaotic 8/9 round

Borderlands won one of the few first-round 8/9 matches that behaved roughly as expected. The writeup uses the result mainly to reiterate that Board 8 tends to overrate the Tales series.

95 4101
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 South Final Fantasy X wins but looks vulnerable

Final Fantasy X recovered from a weak opening but still looked less imposing than a potential contest champion was expected to look. The writeup treats the early struggle as the first clear sign that FFX was vulnerable.

96 4100
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Southeast Kingdom Hearts seizes control of the sequel debate

Kingdom Hearts delivered a much stronger-looking opener than its sequel had and became the clear favorite in their eventual head-to-head matchup. The writeup especially notes its powerful afternoon trend.

97 4099
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Southeast Dissidia exposes Call of Duty's GameFAQs weakness

Modern Warfare 2 won, but Dissidia performed far better than the enormous casual confidence behind Call of Duty suggested it should. The writeup treats the result as another striking example of the site's growing anti-Call-of-Duty sentiment.

98 4098
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Southeast
Halo 2 36.2%
Kingdom Hearts II beats Halo without revealing much

Kingdom Hearts II handled Halo 2 in a surprisingly trendless daytime match despite both series having strong expected afternoon behavior. The writeup considers the result poor evidence for comparing the two Kingdom Hearts games because Halo was so heavily anti-voted.

99 4097
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Southeast
BioShock 68.9%
BioShock opens strong and sparks Kingdom Hearts speculation

BioShock's convincing opener generated immediate speculation that it could beat both Kingdom Hearts games. The writeup sees the performance as evidence that voters were taking the 'Game of the Decade' framing seriously.

100 4096
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Southeast
Shenmue 20.6%
Twilight Princess fuels ZeldaFAQs complaints and title hype

Twilight Princess delivered an elite-looking blowout that triggered another round of ZeldaFAQs complaints. The writeup nevertheless treats the strength shown here as genuinely important for the later Smash matchup.

101 4095
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Southeast
F-Zero GX 30.8%
The writeup mostly turns into an Anagram comedy bit †OT

The writeup is mostly an extended joke about a Board 8 user's long-running Dragon Age rants, with the actual match serving mainly as the setup.

102 4094
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Southeast A 4chan rally helps Pokémon RSE flip GTA IV 1

A heavily debated matchup swung sharply after the afternoon vote and outside support arrived for Pokémon. The writeup celebrates the result as another humiliation for Grand Theft Auto and as a major bracket upset.

Rally: The writeup explicitly says 4chan rallied Pokémon Ruby/Sapphire/Emerald during the close match, contributing to the swing against Grand Theft Auto IV.

103 4093
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Southeast Galaxy's supposedly weak opener ages very differently

Super Mario Galaxy's opening performance was widely read as disappointing at the time because the opposition was assumed to be very weak. The writeup emphasizes how misleading that interpretation looked once Galaxy's later strength became clear.

104 4092
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 East Brawl answers Melee with an even stronger opening

Brawl produced an extraordinary performance against a legitimate Mario Kart game and immediately looked at least as impressive as Melee. The writeup sees the result as the stronger opening statement in their looming divisional showdown.

105 4091
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 East Valkyria Chronicles cements the top-option heuristic

Valkyria Chronicles survived a low-interest fodder matchup that the writeup uses to popularize the 'top option' heuristic. The match stayed relatively close on paper but generated almost no rallying or broader attention.

106 4090
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 East Fire Emblem obliterates a debated wrestling matchup

A matchup that had attracted some Board 8 debate turned into a complete Fire Emblem rout almost immediately. The writeup treats the result as proof that wrestling games had very little contest appeal.

107 4089
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 East Pokémon DPP opens with a major warning sign

Pokémon Diamond, Pearl and Platinum looked much weaker than expected against Metroid Fusion. The writeup treats the result as an early warning that the post-RBY Pokémon games had lost strength rather than as a fluke.

108 4088
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 East Call of Duty 4 wins and still embarrasses itself

Call of Duty 4 won but performed far below the enormous casual confidence placed in it. The writeup treats the showing as another clear example of GameFAQs hostility toward the Call of Duty series.

109 4087
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 East N64 SFF makes Perfect Dark-Conker hard to read 1

Perfect Dark advanced through a matchup the writeup considered almost useless for strength analysis because of the N64 overlap. The commentary finds the presentation more memorable than the competitive result.

SFF: The writeup explicitly calls Perfect Dark versus Conker an N64 SFF match, with the stronger shared-console title suppressing the weaker one.

110 4086
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 East Morrowind reverses Warcraft in a strange PC duel

Morrowind came back from a bad opening to win a close PC-versus-PC matchup that Board 8 had leaned the other way on. The writeup is especially amused that a Blizzard game lost a close contest without the expected rally magic.

111 4085
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 East Melee opens with a historic blowout

Melee delivered one of the contest's largest blowouts and immediately framed the East as a coming Melee-versus-Brawl showdown. The writeup also treats the result as further evidence that rhythm games had collapsed on GameFAQs.

112 4084
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Northeast Half-Life 2 dominates its Valve sibling 1

Half-Life 2 looked extremely strong in an intrafran­chise matchup and became the clear favorite to emerge from the Northeast's lower half. The writeup also uses the result to fuel speculation about a later Metroid Prime comparison.

SFF: The writeup explicitly frames Half-Life 2 versus Left 4 Dead 2 as an SFF match, with the stronger Valve title suppressing the weaker one.

113 4083
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Northeast Grand Theft Auto III's hot start quickly fades

Grand Theft Auto III briefly inspired exaggerated early-match hype before settling into a much more ordinary performance. The writeup treats the final impression as further evidence that Half-Life 2 was the stronger lower-bracket threat.

114 4082
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Northeast God of War strengthens its case against Tales

God of War produced a stable, unsurprising performance against weak opposition. Its clean result made the upcoming Tales of Symphonia matchup look more favorable for God of War than it had before the round.

115 4081
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Northeast Tales survives Resident Evil 5 and keeps the bracket open

Tales of Symphonia survived a matchup where Resident Evil 5 had become a fashionable upset pick. The writeup sees the result as the beginning of a genuinely competitive lower half of the Northeast bracket.

116 4080
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Northeast
Okami 71.4%
Okami keeps gaining legitimacy in a routine win

Okami handled the match exactly as expected and continued its steady rise in GameFAQs legitimacy. The showing also sharply reduced any remaining belief in a Mega Man 9 upset next round.

117 4079
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Northeast Mega Man 9 settles a supposed tossup quickly

A widely debated tossup became much less dramatic once Mega Man 9 took control early. The writeup remembers the match more for how thoroughly it punished a substantial expert lean toward the other side than for any sustained suspense.

118 4078
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Northeast
Mother 3 35.1%
Devil May Cry 3 wins but badly underperforms

Devil May Cry 3 won comfortably but looked much weaker than the writeup and prediction community had expected against an unreleased-in-America Mother 3. The result made DMC3 one of the round's clearest underperformers.

119 4077
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 Northeast Metroid Prime opens the Northeast with authority

Metroid Prime opened the Northeast with the dominant performance expected from a divisional favorite. The writeup treats the match mainly as confirmation that the real questions would come against the stronger games later in the bracket.

120 4076
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 North Halo wins quietly and sets up the series showdown

Halo: Combat Evolved handled Ninja Gaiden without reproducing the character-contest chaos associated with Master Chief and Ryu Hayabusa. The straightforward result instead set up the more meaningful Halo-versus-Halo comparison ahead.

121 4075
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 North
Halo 3 52.5%
Halo 3 ends Super Mario Sunshine hype immediately

Halo 3 beat Super Mario Sunshine and immediately punctured the strong pre-contest hype behind Sunshine. The writeup treats the result as the beginning of a rare positive contest for Halo.

122 4074
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 North Street Fighter IV shocks Sonic Adventure 2

Street Fighter IV upset Sonic Adventure 2 in a result the writeup treats as both long-overdue redemption for the series and a harsh verdict on 3D Sonic games. The match also became a major guru failure.

123 4073
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 North Legend of Dragoon validates itself in defeat

Uncharted 2 beat The Legend of Dragoon, but the writeup considered Dragoon's respectable showing proof that its vote-in success had been legitimate. Uncharted remained on course for the deeper run many expected.

124 4072
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 North
Fable 50.0%
Team Fortress 2 survives an all-time Fable thriller

Team Fortress 2 and Fable traded the lead repeatedly for nearly the entire poll, producing one of the closest wire-to-wire matches the writeup could remember. Team Fortress 2's dedicated fanbase and bracket support proved just enough to survive.

125 4071
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 North Batman cruises through an uninformative opener

Batman overwhelmed Psychonauts in a match the writeup considered almost entirely devoid of useful information. Psychonauts was simply too weak to reveal much about Batman's later prospects.

126 4070
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 North
Deus Ex 50.8%
Deus Ex extends the second-match jinx

Deus Ex upset Rock Band 2 and joined the long tradition of second-match bracket wreckers. The writeup says the apparent closeness was misleading because Deus Ex built a lead early and merely gave some of it back later, while Europe's stronger support proved important.

127 4069
writeup (md)
GOTD Round 1 North
Fallout 3 81.0%
inFamous 19.0%
Fallout 3 opens Game of the Decade with authority

Fallout 3 opened the Game of the Decade contest with a dominant win and immediately established itself as a serious entry. The writeup notes the unusual absence of Nintendo from the traditional opening slot.

What this is

Each row's Headline and (on filter) narrative come from a ChatGPT reading of that match's Board 8 wiki writeup. The five flags (SFF same-fanbase factor, LFF low-fanbase factor, Rally outside rally, Cheat cheating alleged, Pic match-picture factor) are set only when the writeup asserts that effect — never inferred from the numbers. Hover a check for the note. †OT marks a writeup that mostly wanders off the match.

Want to do your own AI assisted research? Board 8 wiki pages are available in markdown format here.